The Deferred Sales Trust in California: What the FTB Rules Actually Say

Estate Planning Team's Deferred Sales Trust in California rests on the federal installment sale rules of Internal Revenue Code Section 453, and California conforms to those rules by statute.

Canal-front home in Venice, California at dusk with palm trees

Four further issues apply at the state level:

Advisors need all four settled before the transaction closes, whether the client is a California resident or a nonresident who owns property in the state. Each is addressed below, using the state's published guidance.

How the Structure Works

The mechanism behind the Deferred Sales Trust is the same in California as anywhere else, and the order of events is what matters.

  1. The seller transfers the appreciated asset to the trust in exchange for a promissory note.

  2. The trust sells the asset to a third-party buyer.

  3. The trust receives the sales proceeds.

  4. The pre-tax sales proceeds are invested by the trust.

  5. The trust repays the seller over time under the terms of the note, and capital gains are recognized as principal payments are received.

At closing, the sales proceeds go to the trust, not to the seller. The seller, therefore, recognizes gain over the repayment period rather than in the year of sale. The strategy defers tax. It does not remove it. The sequence is what is important, so the trust has to be in place before the transaction closes.

How Does California Tax a Deferred Sales Trust?

California treats capital gains as ordinary income. There is no preferential long-term rate.

12.3% Top bracket
1% Behavioral Health Services Tax
13.3% Top marginal rate

California’s top marginal personal income-tax rate is 13.3%, combining the 12.3% top bracket with the 1% Behavioral Health Services Tax on taxable income above $1 million. Because California taxes capital gains as ordinary income, a large single-year gain can therefore carry a materially higher state tax cost than the same gain recognized across several years.

The installment method changes when gain is recognized, not what rate applies to it. Each repayment is taxed under the law in effect for the year it is received, so a seller who spreads recognition across multiple years is managing bracket exposure rather than fixing a rate. Sellers report installment sale income to the state on FTB Form 3805E, the California counterpart to federal Form 6252.

California FTB Form 3805E
Federal counterpart Form 6252

California Source Income and Installment Repayments

Two separate rules govern how California reaches a gain, and advisors evaluating a relocation should keep them apart.

The first rule

Residency

The first is residency. California taxes residents on income from all sources, wherever earned.

The second rule

Source

The second is the source. Gain from the sale of real property is California source income because the property sits in California, and that remains true regardless of where the seller lives when the gain is recognized. A seller who moves to Nevada after a California sale does not move the source of the gain.

The Deferred Sales Trust adds a layer to that analysis. Repayments to the seller arise under a promissory note issued by the trust rather than directly from the disposition of the property, and the characterization of those repayments depends on the facts of the arrangement. Sellers weighing a move should raise the question with a tax attorney before the structure is set, not after the first repayment arrives. Estate Planning Team's network includes DST attorneys who review these fact patterns.

What FTB Notice 2019-05 Says About the California Deferred Sales Trust

Notice 2019-05 is the document most often cited in discussions of the California Deferred Sales Trust.

FTB Notice 2019-05 at a glance

Issued
September 24, 2019, by the Franchise Tax Board
Type
Penalty document
Targets
Qualified intermediaries who actively participate in improper like-kind exchanges
Penalty
Greater of $500 or 10% of the amount that should have been withheld (R&TC §18668(d))
Applies to
Attempted like-kind exchanges with property relinquished on or after March 24, 2020

The Franchise Tax Board issued the notice on September 24, 2019. It is a penalty document. The subject line targets “qualified intermediaries who actively participate” in like-kind exchange transactions that the Board describes as improper, and the penalty at issue is for failure to withhold.

The arrangement the notice describes is specific. A taxpayer or qualified intermediary converts boot, or the proceeds from a failed or partial like-kind exchange, into an installment note or similar arrangement paid out over two or more years. The Franchise Tax Board states that such arrangements do not allow deferral of gain recognition under IRC Sections 453 and 1031, citing the federal doctrine of constructive receipt among its reasons.

The penalty runs against the intermediary. Under Revenue and Taxation Code Section 18668(d), a person required to withhold who fails to do so owes the greater of $500 or 10% of the amount that should have been withheld, absent reasonable cause. The notice applies to attempted like-kind exchanges in which property is relinquished on or after March 24, 2020.

Three points follow from the text:

The notice addresses withholding

Its operative mechanism is a penalty for failure to withhold, not a prohibition on any particular structure.

The notice addresses attempted exchanges

The transaction it describes begins with a like-kind exchange that failed or was only partially completed.

Constructive receipt is the reasoning

The concern is a taxpayer who has already constructively received proceeds and then attempts to recharacterize them.

Note

Whether a particular arrangement falls inside or outside the scope of the notice is a legal question that turns on facts, and one that belongs with tax counsel rather than with marketing material.

Real Estate Withholding on a California Sale

California requires withholding on the disposition of a California real property interest, and the rules differ depending on how the sale is structured.

Buyer withholds

Sale at closing.

When a California property sells at closing, the buyer withholds 3 1/3% of the sales price. The parties can elect an alternative calculation instead, based on the gain the seller has to recognize rather than on the full price. Revenue and Taxation Code Section 18662 and its implementing regulation, Title 18 Section 18662-3, impose the requirement.

Intermediary withholds

Failed like-kind exchange

Where a like-kind exchange fails, does not occur, or does not meet the requirements of IRC Section 1031, the intermediary or accommodator must withhold on the same basis.

Buyer withholds per payment

Seller-financed installment sale

Seller-financed installment sales work differently. When California real estate is sold on an installment basis, the buyer withholds on the principal portion of each installment payment, at either 3 1/3% of the total sales price or the optional gain on sale amount. Withholding applies to the principal portion only. FTB 4010 and FTB Publication 1016 set out the mechanics.

How the DST differs

That last rule describes a sale in which the buyer of the property pays the seller over time. The Deferred Sales Trust is a different arrangement. The buyer purchases from the trust, and the note runs from the trust back to the seller. Advisors should confirm with the trustee and with counsel how withholding is handled at the closing itself.

State Conformity and IRC Section 453

For personal income tax purposes, California generally conforms to IRC §453 under Revenue and Taxation Code §§17551 and 17560, subject to California modifications. For corporation tax purposes, conformity to the installment-sale rules runs through §§24667 and 24668.1. California also conforms to IRC §1031 under §§18031 and 18031.5 for personal income tax and §24941 for corporation tax.

Federal rule Personal income tax Corporation tax
IRC §453 R&TC §§17551 and 17560 §§24667 and 24668.1
IRC §1031 §§18031 and 18031.5 §24941

The practical consequence for a California Deferred Sales Trust is that the federal installment treatment is generally available at the state level as well, subject to the same requirements. The difference is timing rather than treatment. Advisors should confirm the current year instructions for FTB Form 3805E before relying on any specific reporting position.

Deferred Sales Trust and 1031 Exchange Compared

A 1031 exchange and the Deferred Sales Trust both defer capital gains tax, and both are available to California sellers. They suit different situations.

Deferred Sales Trust 1031 Exchange
Eligible assets Real estate, private businesses, investment portfolios, cryptocurrency, art, and collectibles Like-kind real property
Deadlines No identification or closing deadline 45 days to identify, 180 days to close
Replacement requirement None required Replacement property of equal or greater value
Capital Gain recognition As repayments are received Deferred until a taxable disposition
When the choice is made Before the transaction closes Before the relinquished property closes

Both routes depend on completed structuring before the transaction closes, which is why sellers uncertain about meeting exchange deadlines benefit from evaluating the alternative early. Estate Planning Team supports both, and members work with real estate professionals on either path.

Deferred Sales Trust vs. 1031 Exchange

How Estate Planning Team Supports California Advisors

Estate Planning Team is a national membership organization for financial and legal professionals, headquartered in Indian Wells, California. Our members gain access to the Deferred Sales Trust and the support required to bring it to clients.

Membership includes access to our network of tax and legal professionals who structure and execute these transactions, turnkey marketing materials, a personalized lead generation website, a web-based tracking system, client presentations, and professional partner referrals. Members serve financial advisors, CPAs and tax professionals, attorneys, and real estate professionals across the state.

Advisors weighing the Deferred Sales Trust in California for a client can join Estate Planning Team to work through the structure with professionals who handle these transactions regularly.

Join Now

Frequently Asked Questions

Before the transaction closes. The structure depends on the seller transferring the asset to the trust before the sale to the end buyer, which means the trust has to exist and be documented in advance. A seller who has already closed, or who has constructively received the sales proceeds, no longer has that option.

A professional independent trustee administers the trust and manages the sales proceeds. The seller is a creditor of the trust rather than an owner or controller of it, holds a promissory note secured by the trust assets, and has a creditor’s right to approve the trust’s investments. The note provides for interest on pre-tax sales proceeds.

Commercial and residential real estate, privately held businesses, investment portfolios, private stocks, cryptocurrency, artwork, and collectibles. The breadth is the main structural difference from a 1031 exchange, which applies to like-kind real property. Asset type affects valuation and trustee administration, so advisors should review specifics before the structure is set.

Sellers file Form 3805E with the California return for each year a repayment is received, rather than once at the time of sale. Sellers who elect out of the installment method and report the entire gain in the year of sale do not use the form at all. Reporting instructions change between revisions, so advisors should check the current version each filing season.

The Deferred Sales Trust may not be suitable for all sellers. Consult with your tax and legal advisors before proceeding.

This material is for educational purposes only and is not intended as tax, legal, or financial advice.